Been There, Done That. Is it time to renegotiate Thanksgiving traditions?

We value our traditions, especially during the holidays. They give us a sense of security. We know what to expect and what we’re expected to do. 

 

So, with Thanksgiving upon us, do we stick to the same old, or do we change it up a lot or a little? Thanksgiving is rife with traditions. Tweak them, and you can spark a full-fledged family revolt. There are two schools: those who want to maintain control, cook most of the meal, if not all, and host it at home. They make the same menu every year and love setting the same beautiful table and bringing out their best china and silver. On the other hand, some can’t wait to try something new, mix it up, even use disposables and hope the results stick despite valiant efforts.

 

If willing to substitute turkey as the main dish, The New York Times has a feature (Nov. 17, 2020) on 23 Thanksgiving main dishes that are better than turkey: https://cooking.nytimes.com/article/thanksgiving-main-dish-not-turkey. Try one before the holiday and you might get hooked.

 

But for those of us who enjoy cooking--and especially baking--we think it’s more fun and interesting not to be a slave to tradition and prepare the same-old menus year after year. Maybe we substitute grilled salmon for turkey or add it to the menu.  One family we know loves fried chicken. The green bean casserole might be made from scratch rather than the traditional canned mushroom soup topped with Durkee’s fried onions. Don’t ask us how we feel about that.

 

The turkey can be carved differently or even cooked outdoors. You can substitute chocolate cake for pumpkin pie or add lemon-lime meringue pie for a refreshing Southern twist. We even change the dishes we’ve used in the past, add new placemats, new holiday-themed decorations, flowers or a festive tablecloth or a paper runner little kids can color. These are benign changes that shouldn’t cause a ruckus.

 

And for those of us who have consistently hosted the holiday over the years, we may hope someone else takes charge, as it is so much work. “We’re getting too old for this,” we say. “It’s difficult to stand on our feet for too long cooking and cleaning up.” Let the next generation pick up the mantle or whisk and gravy ladle.

 

With tradition front and center, we came up with three questions that many might ask themselves before Thanksgiving Day arrives. And they are:


What tradition do you insist on?

What tradition do you look forward to most?

What tradition do you wish would disappear? 


As we often do, we reached out to our readers for answers to these questions. Some answered all, and others did not. Here’s the feedback we received. 

 

Barbara:

--One tradition we all insist on: We all go around the table and say what we are grateful for, but we do something beyond being glad that we’re together.

--A few traditions I look forward to: Making my homemade cornbread stuffing, making my cranberry sauce, studying the food magazines I get before the holiday to see some new interesting ideas such as last year’s cranberry curd tart, and finally, having great leftovers.

--One that’s been added is taking a long walk before we sit down or after we eat.

--One tradition I wish would change: The next generation takes it over permanently since standing on our feet to do all the prep and shopping is getting so much harder; yes, everyone helps but…..And already this year my wish has been granted.


Margaret: 

--One tradition I insist on is having a turkey and turkey breast. No substitutes, please. And pumpkin pie.

--One tradition I look forward to: Getting as many family members together as possible for a very traditional dinner which has been hosted for the past seven years by my youngest sister. 

--One tradition I wish would change: Too many desserts that are either too time-consuming to make from scratch or expensive if bought. One dessert, depending on the number of people who are at the feast, should suffice. Maybe two if a large group.

Liza:

--I insist on someone saying grace before the feast.              

 --I love taking a walk in the autumn air after the meal.

 -- Good riddance to watching Thanksgiving football games on TV!

 

Ettalee:

--On tradition, I insist on having: Sweet potato pie.

--One tradition I look forward to: My family being together.

--One tradition I wish I could change: Someone doing something obscene with the cooked turkey neck.

H:

--One tradition I insist on: a traditional Mexican meal that I look forward to since my parents are from Mexico.

--One tradition I look forward to: They have a nutty drink called Atole that’s corn-based and seasoned with cinnamon, vanilla, chocolate (known as champurrado) or seasonal fruits. We don’t eat turkey but eat tamales wrapped in corn husks (hojas de maíz), made from corn masa dough and filled with a savory or sweet filling, often of crushed corn, meat and beans that are steamed and unwrapped before eating. We have a lot of traditional American pies.

 Rena:

--I think the menu stands out for me.  But the menu isn’t especially interesting or different. It’s just that I repeat what my mother did. I feel close to her when I cook Greek green beans, sautéed with Olive oil, sliced onion and tomato, cooked until soft.

--The tradition I look forward to is being at home for the Thanksgiving holiday.  Creating an inviting and comfortable atmosphere in my home and welcoming family and friends begins the tradition of the days until the end of the year.  A time to be thankful, kind and generous, hopeful and optimistic.

--I don’t think I have a tradition that I don’t look forward to at Thanksgiving…after all, I like Pumpkin Pie
! 

Jill:

--What I wish I could add is having all my children and grandchildren around the table together, but with our son in Belgium, where there is no holiday time off for Thanksgiving, I feel that that is a wish that will remain a wish, not a reality.

--As for what to keep, we take the children and go and search outside for anything that might make a fall centerpiece--tall grasses, dried flowers--and work with the children to assemble it.

--We are not a religious family, but it's the only time we say grace before a meal and then go around the table to ask each person what they are grateful for. 

Susie:

--Traditional Thanksgiving meal.  Turkey, mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes, green beans, stuffing, pumpkin pie, apple pie, pecan pie, cranberries.  No counting calories on this day.

--Getting together with family.

--No tradition to disappear. 

Estelle: 

What tradition do you insist upon? I make the soup and cranberry sauce before Thanksgiving Day. On that day, I roast the turkey, make the stuffing, a corn pudding and mashed potatoes. Others bring the sweet potato casserole and vegies. All the desserts are brought by others.

What tradition do you look forward to most? The tradition of going around the table to say what we are thankful for remains. Also, getting kitchen help for both Thursday and Friday has become an absolute must. Friday is more informal but we have twice the amount of people but don’t hesitate to use plastic plates. 

What tradition do you wish would disappear? She doesn’t have one

Deborah (private chef):

What she looks forward to: I insist that it must be celebrated with friends and family, either at my home or another’s

She looks forward to the most: cooking with loved ones.

What she’d like to get rid of: Black Friday should disappear.

What she always serves: Cranberry Walnut tart from a 1980s Gourmet magazine, five-onion casserole, cheddar chive biscuits

Maura Carlin, co-podcast host, The Balance Dilemma

What traditions she follows: For Thanksgiving, we’ve always gathered and, for the last 25 or so years, with few exceptions, it’s been at my home. My mom’s stuffing is always expected (tougher in recent years, as I now have to make it lol), and year after year I forget to serve the cranberry compote. 

A new tradition she’s started: I’ve started a new tradition in the last few years, though. Since we no longer have highly helpful “buffer guests,” my pre-meal activity is Cosmos and Bingo. Puts everyone in a good, well-behaved mood, and we have fun!


The best Thanksgiving dinner, regardless of where, what is served, and how the table is set, offers memories that last a long time… and a few extra meals besides. And then there’s an entire year to debate about what to keep and give up.


2 comments

  • Rena Abrams

    I enjoyed reading everyone’s stories. Since there will only be three of us this year – they wanted to go out, so I said okay. I will still make my cranberry jello, though.
    Best wishes for a wonderful Thanksgiving and holiday season.
    Rena

  • Marty Boxer

    Cooking the turkey outdoors on my Weber kettle

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published